Jeff Bakalar’s
recent post on killing portable consoles sparked off some tech anger. Now for my two cents.
And, let me say first that I like Jeff and respect his opinions in the tech and gaming worlds. Unlike with the
Buzz Out Loud podcasts, I've never considered not listening to
The 404 anymore because of any opinions expressed in a particular episode by Jeff, Justin, or Wilson. (My irritation with
Buzz Out Loud is a subject for another post entirely.) However, I found several flaws in his argument.
"Current consumers are more concerned with brief sessions of stimulation than they are with playing a complex 25-hour RPG."
Portable consoles are obviously not for people who want 20 minutes of entertainment.
Angry Birds and similar simplistic games that are available as apps are no different from those little Video Poker, Blackjack, and Sudoku games that were popular with commuters long before anyone ever heard of an iPhone. But, me? I
still want the 25-hour RPG or survival horror title on my PSP, because I'm playing it at my desk or in bed or somewhere else when there's more than 20 minutes to kill. If I only have 20 minutes, I read the
New York Times.
"[If] consumers are content with an iPhone for music, video, and games, there is absolutely no practical need to carry around another bulky piece of hardware [...]."
There is truth in the idea that many consumers want electronics that will be their phone, calendar, email and Web access, music player, and anything else they can cram into it, including a bagel toaster - if they can manage that, too. Except, I don't own an iPhone, and I don't want my phone to be my catchall device. I like having a separate MP3 player, separate laptop, etc.
"Though it's most likely due to a dearth of compelling titles and an audience not completely on-board with 3D on the go, Nintendo's 3DS has stumbled out of the gate."
I agree that these are two reasons that the 3DS has not caught on. Another is that we're in a recession that has hit even the most hardcore of gamers. Console manufacturers have to work harder for our money. And, when there is a wealth of critics saying that the 3DS isn't worth our cash, we're not going to look twice at the 3DS. We'll wait for the Vita.
"There's no denying its massive 5-inch touch screen and jaw-dropping graphics will make for the most powerful portable system ever, but its place in the American marketplace is quickly evaporating. "
I disagree that the marketplace is evaporating. Truncating, yes. But then, people who collect baseball cards have long been a dying breed, and yet,
Topps still makes baseball cards. For who? Die-hard collectors. Buyers who still find value in a fresh pack of baseball cards, be those buyers 12 years old or 50 years old.
Like those die-hard card collectors, we hardcore gamers will always put cash on the counter and find room in our backpacks for a crazy-cool device. The Vita looks like it will be one of those devices. I say to the naysayers that portable consoles are not dead, it's just harder to come by a really good one.